Archive for the ‘Korea, North’ Category

Korea: Ah Hah! WMD

Tuesday, October 10th, 2006

John McCain is attacking Bill Clinton for allowing NorKor to have nukes, showing once again what Mad Gop disease does to a man’s brain. Mr. Incompetence, McCain’s daddy, is just lost in the cavities for a while.

“I would remind Sen Clinton and other Democrats critical of the Bush Administration’s policies that the framework agreement her husband’s administration negotiated was a failure,” McCain said.

National Journal

If you’d like to know what really happened with Korea during Clinton’s tenure you can start with Fred Kaplan’s piece for Washington Monthly.

And of course these are not simply “You Stoopid!” — “No, You Stoopid!” arguments.

Nobody knows precisely what North Korea has. This is what makes negotiations both difficult and necessary. Bush’s failure to make a deal, while the fuel rods were still locked up, constitutes one of the great diplomatic blunders of our time. It may not be too late to avert the coming disaster. The question is whether the president–whoever he might be–recognizes that a disaster is coming, decides to deal with it, and does so fairly soon. The time is already late; at some point, it will run out.

William Arkin, the WaPo’s security columnist — and no friend of Clinton’s plan — has this to say.

What we are really witnessing is government at its worst, not just promising a capability on which it cannot deliver, but worse, communicating American resolve and toughness on the one hand while exposing weakness and impotence when it matters.

Arkin on WMD

North Korea – Nukes

Monday, October 9th, 2006

You’ve seen the news — Korea has apparently set off an underground nuclear explosion. (If not, scan down the page.) Much is in flux at the moment, but here’s a good start-up analysis from Josh Marshall.

North Korea’s nuclear program has been a problem for US presidents going back to Reagan, and the conflict between North and South has been a key issue for US presidents going back to Truman. As recently as 1994, the US came far closer to war with North Korea than most Americans realize.

President Clinton eventually concluded a complicated and multipart agreement in which the North Koreans would suspend their production of plutonium in exchange for fuel oil, help building light water nuclear reactors (the kind that don’t help making bombs) and a vague promise of diplomatic normalization.

President Bush came to office believing that Clinton’s policy amounted to appeasement. Force and strength were the way to deal with North Korea, not a mix of force, diplomacy and aide. And with that premise, President Bush went about scuttling the 1994 agreement, using evidence that the North Koreans were pursuing uranium enrichment (another path to the bomb) as the final straw.

Remember the guiding policy of the early Bush years: Clinton did it=Bad, Bush=Not whatever Clinton did.

All diplomatic niceties aside, President Bush’s idea was that the North Koreans would respond better to threats than Clinton’s mix of carrots and sticks.

Then in the winter of 2002-3, as the US was preparing to invade Iraq, the North called Bush’s bluff. And the president folded. Abjectly, utterly, even hilariously if the consequences weren’t so grave and vast.

Talking Points Memo

North Korea — Oh, Never Mind

Thursday, June 29th, 2006

Hoax Watch, Day 10: No Nork Launch, After All

North Korea Update

Sunday, June 25th, 2006

Matt Stoller at MyDD points us to a good post at DefenseTech.org, with info from all sorts of connected people about the posturing over the missle already ripping through the imagination of many watchers.

Missle Hype?